FACTS
The U.S. government may aim persuasion at foreign audiences, but federal law limits what it may spend to persuade Americans, and the public record shows both limits have been tested. This analysis separates what the law says, what has been documented, and what is still only alleged.
The question returns whenever Washington’s media operations make news, most recently in the court fight over Voice of America. Claims in that fight often go beyond the evidence. Here is what primary sources support.
What Smith-Mundt does and doesn’t allow
The Smith-Mundt Modernization Act changed who may receive government-made international broadcasts. It did not authorize deception. A 2012 Congressional Research Service report explains that a 1972 amendment to the 1948 Smith-Mundt Act and a 1985 provision known as the Zorinsky Amendment prohibited domestic dissemination of material prepared for foreign audiences.
Congress rewrote those provisions in section 1078 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2013, Public Law 112-239, signed January 2, 2013. The change took effect 180 days later. As codified at 22 U.S.C. 1461, it lets the State Department and the agency now called the U.S. Agency for Global Media (USAGM) make material produced for foreign audiences available in the United States on request.
The same law kept a domestic limit, now at 22 U.S.C. 1461-1a: “No funds authorized to be appropriated to the Department of State or the Broadcasting Board of Governors shall be used to influence public opinion in the United States.” A fact-check by The Dispatch also rebutted a popular claim that the law was repealed. It was amended, not repealed.
Nothing in section 1078 mentions false statements or a national-security exception for them. We found no record of the government citing the Act that way.
The real guardrail: the “covert propaganda” rule
The main limit on domestic persuasion by federal agencies in general is a spending rule. Appropriations laws have long said no funds may be used “for publicity or propaganda purposes within the United States not heretofore authorized by the Congress,” as the Government Accountability Office (GAO) told Congress in 2005. GAO reads that to bar agency material that is “covert as to origin.”
GAO applied the rule twice in 2005. In January it found that prepackaged news stories made for the Office of National Drug Control Policy did not disclose the agency’s role and were covert propaganda. In September it found that the Education Department violated the rule when it paid, through the public relations firm Ketchum, for commentary by Armstrong Williams that did not disclose the department’s sponsorship.
The executive branch has not always agreed. In a March 2005 memo, the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel said the rule does not apply “where there is no advocacy of a particular viewpoint” and told agencies they are not bound by GAO’s legal advice. How far the rule reaches remains disputed between the two branches.
Three documented cases
Gulf of Tonkin (1964). A second reported attack on U.S. ships on August 4, 1964, did not happen, according to a study by NSA historian Robert J. Hanyok that the agency declassified in 2005. The National Security Archive’s summary says Hanyok concluded that agency officials “mishandled” signals intelligence and gave top officials “skewed” intelligence supporting the attack claim. Hanyok said he did not find a “smoking gun” showing a cover-up. A companion article NSA released, by Louis F. Giles, the agency’s director of policy and records, accepted that no attack took place but rejected the view that the intelligence was deliberately skewed or withheld.
Unattributed “news” (early 2000s). The GAO findings above show agencies packaging government messaging as independent reporting for domestic audiences.
Pentagon campaign abroad (2020 to 2021). A June 2024 Reuters investigation, republished by Al Jazeera, reported that the U.S. military ran a secret campaign from spring 2020 to mid-2021 to undermine China’s Sinovac vaccine, starting in the Philippines and later aimed at Central Asia and the Middle East. Reuters identified at least 300 accounts on X, which X removed after Reuters asked about them. A senior Defense Department official acknowledged the effort to Reuters and said new controls followed a 2021 internal review.
In a July 2024 Reuters follow-up, Pentagon spokesman Pete Nguyen said an initial review “found that the U.S. military was not responsible for the troubling social media content related to the Philippines” that Reuters had cited. He also acknowledged that the Pentagon distributed content about Sinovac’s safety and efficacy. The reporting describes foreign audiences as the campaign’s targets.
The current fight: Voice of America
The live dispute is over what remains of USAGM, which oversees Voice of America (VOA). The administration has largely shut VOA down. As of mid-November 2026 it was broadcasting in eight languages and had not resumed English broadcasts, according to a timeline kept by SaveVOA, a site run by VOA journalists.
On March 23, 2026, four VOA journalists, joined by PEN America and Reporters Without Borders, sued USAGM, acting CEO Michael Rigas and Kari Lake in federal court in Washington. The suit, Newhouse v. U.S. Agency for Global Media, alleges that VOA’s remaining broadcasts repeat White House talking points and suppress news the administration wants downplayed, in violation of the First Amendment and the law shielding VOA’s newsroom from political interference.
USAGM said in a statement to the AP that taxpayer money must support broadcasting that reflects U.S. policy, and that the agency is responsible for “ensuring compliance with the VOA charter.” Lake, who led the agency’s cuts, has described VOA’s past coverage very differently from the plaintiffs. At a June 25, 2025 House hearing she called the agency “rotten to its core” and cited coverage she described as biased.
Courts have ruled in related cases. On March 7, 2026, U.S. District Judge Royce C. Lamberth ruled in Widakuswara v. Lake that Lake was not lawfully serving as the agency’s acting CEO and declared her actions void, including the layoffs. Lake told NPR she would appeal. On March 31, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit paused the part of a later order that required employees on administrative leave to return to work while the appeal proceeds. On November 10, the same court upheld an injunction barring USAGM from removing VOA director Michael Abramowitz without the board approval the law requires.
In the Newhouse case, the government has asked the court to dismiss the suit, arguing the plaintiffs lack standing, according to the SaveVOA timeline. We found no ruling on that request.
Congress is also revisiting Smith-Mundt. H.R. 5704, introduced October 8, 2025 by Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) with Rep. Scott Perry (R-Pa.), would undo the 2013 change and provide that “No program material prepared by USAGM may be distributed in the United States,” with limited exceptions. It was referred to the House Foreign Affairs Committee, and government bill records show no action since.
The lawsuit’s claims are allegations, and the bill is a proposal. The litigation is still moving, so check for updates before relying on this section.
What we can and can’t say
The record supports three conclusions:
- Officials have told the public things the government’s own later records contradict, with the reported August 4, 1964 Tonkin attack as the clearest declassified example.
- Agencies have hidden their role in domestic messaging, and GAO has ruled that unlawful, though the executive branch disputes how far the rule reaches.
- The U.S. military has run covert influence operations abroad, one of which a senior Defense official acknowledged.
The record does not show that Smith-Mundt lets officials lie, or that national security is a legal license to deceive Americans. The reporting on the Pentagon vaccine campaign describes foreign targets, not domestic ones. Claims that the government is lying about current events need their own evidence.
Sources and methodology
This is analysis built from public laws, agency decisions, court records and published reporting. Stay Current News did not conduct interviews or file records requests for it. Primary sources are listed first. Reuters stories are linked through copies republished by Reuters clients. Details on VOA’s current broadcast schedule and the pending motion in the Newhouse case come from SaveVOA, a site run by VOA journalists, and are attributed to it.
