FACTS
Strict school phone bans lead to small gains in test scores, about one to two weeks of extra learning a year, according to new research led by Harvard economist Thomas Kane, the Harvard Gazette reported on Nov. 17. A separate Stanford study found no test score gains over three years but signs of better student well-being.
What the Harvard study found on school phone bans
Kane’s team, working with researchers at Dartmouth, looked at test results for about 3.3 million students from the 2021-22 school year through 2025-26, using NWEA MAP tests, Chalkbeat reported. The work was done with the Center for Education Policy Research’s States Leading States Initiative.
The bans raised scores by about 0.01 standard deviations a year, the Gazette reported. That is roughly half of the 0.02 standard deviation drop in scores each year since 2013. Kane said the bans “seem to plug about half of that leak,” NPR reported.
“A strict cell phone ban is a low-cost way to add one to two weeks of instruction per year,” Kane said, according to Chalkbeat.
NPR noted that the Harvard study has not yet been peer reviewed.
Researchers urge caution
“These are really small, sensitive estimates that fall short of the ambitions many of us had for school phone bans,” said Dartmouth economist Tom Dee, according to Chalkbeat.
An earlier peer-reviewed study by Dee and Brian Jacob found effects “close to zero,” NPR reported. “We didn’t find evidence of meaningful achievement gains,” Jacob said.
Kane said more data is coming. “I guarantee you that there are some surprises to be found in those data,” he told the Gazette. “So we ought not to just shoot from the hip.”
The Stanford study
A study led by Stanford economist Matthew Gentzkow surveyed about 108,000 teachers at 4,600 schools, the Stanford Report said. It found no test score gains over three years, but measures of student well-being trended higher.
“A key thing that has been missing from the conversation about phones and kids is clear data on school cell phone policies,” Gentzkow said.
Where bans stand
About three-quarters of states now restrict student phone use in schools, Chalkbeat reported. Pennsylvania adopted a bell-to-bell ban in October, meaning phones are put away from the first bell to the last.
For parents, the research suggests bans are a modest help for learning, not a cure for falling scores.
For more school and family news, visit the Stay Current News U.S. section.



