U.S.

Judge extends block on Trump memorial arch by 14 days

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan kept construction of a 250-foot arch at Memorial Circle on hold until early December while she weighs a longer pause.

Memorial Circle on Columbia Island in Washington, seen from Arlington Memorial Bridge between two stone pillars topped with eagles, looking toward Arlington National Cemetery
File photo: G. Edward Johnson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

FACTS

A federal judge on Wednesday, Nov. 18, extended her order blocking construction of a planned 250-foot Trump memorial arch at Memorial Circle in Washington by 14 days, The Associated Press reported. U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan’s temporary restraining order now runs until Dec. 3, or until she rules on a request for a preliminary injunction, whichever comes first.

Why the Trump memorial arch is on hold

Chutkan first issued the order on Nov. 5, after the National Capital Planning Commission gave the project final approval by an 8-4 vote, according to AP. The order had been set to expire Thursday.

Memorial Circle is a traffic circle on Columbia Island, between Arlington Memorial Bridge and Arlington National Cemetery. It sits along the view between the Lincoln Memorial and the cemetery, where President John F. Kennedy is buried.

A temporary restraining order is a short court order meant to keep things as they are until a judge can hear fuller arguments. It usually lasts only days or weeks, which is why Chutkan had to decide whether to extend it.

Who is suing

Several groups have challenged the arch, AP reported:

  • Three Vietnam veterans and a retired architectural historian
  • The District of Columbia and Virginia, which sued on Oct. 31 in a case that was combined with the veterans’ case
  • Members of the Kennedy family, who sued on Nov. 10
  • A fourth lawsuit is pending in federal court in the Eastern District of Virginia

The plaintiffs argue that Congress must approve the project and that the arch would disrupt historic sightlines between the memorials and the cemetery.

The government’s position

Lawyers for the administration argue that Congress cleared a monument at Memorial Circle decades ago, so no new approval is needed, according to AP. They say construction can go ahead once the Interior Department issues its final decision and the National Park Service gives notice.

What happens next

Chutkan will weigh whether to grant a preliminary injunction, which would keep the project on hold while the lawsuits move forward. That is a higher bar than a temporary order. Courts usually look at whether the challengers are likely to win, whether they would suffer harm that cannot be undone, and the public interest.

If Chutkan denies the injunction, the government could move to begin work. If she grants it, the administration could appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit.

For more national news, visit the Stay Current News U.S. section.