Entertainment

Google declines to remove Russell Brand YouTube video

The prison service for England and Wales asked for the video, in which Laura Brand reads a message from her jailed husband, to be taken down. Google said its rules were not broken, the BBC reported.

Russell Brand speaking at a demonstration in London
File photo: D B Young / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

FACTS

Google declined a request from the prison service for England and Wales to take down a Russell Brand YouTube video in which his wife, Laura Brand, reads a message from him, the BBC reported Thursday, Nov. 19. Google said its rules had not been broken, according to the BBC. Brand is serving a sentence of 10 years and six months for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault.

What the prison service asked for

The Prison Service of England and Wales formally asked for the video to be removed because it believed the video was offensive to Brand’s victims and had reached a substantial audience, BBC News reported, citing Whitehall sources. The request was made through an established mechanism the prison service has with technology companies for asking them to delete material, according to the BBC report, as republished by MyJoyOnline.

The BBC said it was first told that a minister had met Google to ask for Brand’s account to be deactivated. The Ministry of Justice later clarified that the request focused on the video and that no minister met Google, the BBC reported.

A Ministry of Justice spokesperson told the BBC: “It is only right that the Government asks for content that is distressing for victims to be taken down,” Yahoo News reported. The spokesperson also said removal “ultimately depends on the platform’s own terms,” according to the BBC.

Google’s response on the Russell Brand YouTube video

Google refused the request on the basis that its rules had not been broken, the BBC reported, according to ABC News Australia. In a statement to the BBC, Google said it was aware of the new content and that its teams were investigating.

“We suspended Russell Brand’s channel from the YouTube Partner Program in September 2023,” a Google spokesperson said, adding that the channel has not been able to earn money on YouTube since then, according to the BBC and Yahoo News. The channel has about 6.6 million subscribers, Yahoo News and ABC News reported.

The video

Laura Brand posted the video on the couple’s YouTube channel on Sunday, Nov. 15, as part of their weekly “Sunday Service with the Brands,” Variety reported. In the message she read, Brand said he was not guilty of the offences for which he was jailed, according to the BBC. He also thanked supporters and praised staff at HMP Littlehey, the prison in Cambridgeshire where he is held, Yahoo News reported.

Government response

Downing Street called the message “clearly appalling” and said, “Prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims,” the BBC reported. Justice Secretary Alex Norris said the matter was being “urgently investigated, and I expect action to be taken if he is found to have broken the rules,” according to the BBC. If he is found to have broken prison rules, Brand could lose privileges such as phone access, Yahoo News reported.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham urged social media companies to take the material down and said, “Show some decency,” ABC News reported, citing AFP. Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook told the BBC the government cannot force removal and said, “That is up to Google,” according to ABC News. An Ofcom spokesperson said the current guidance was ultimately voluntary, the BBC reported.

The conviction and sentence

Brand was convicted at Southwark Crown Court of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault against four women between 2004 and 2009, and he was sentenced on Monday, Nov. 9, to 10 years and six months in prison, according to a Crown Prosecution Service statement. The CPS announced the conviction on Nov. 5.

Brand was acquitted of two counts of rape and one charge of attempted indecent assault, ITV News reported. Brand denied all the charges at trial and said the encounters were consensual, according to ITV News. He maintains his innocence, according to the message his wife read.

Meta disabled Brand’s Instagram and Facebook accounts under its policy on accounts owned by convicted sex offenders, Variety reported. His YouTube channel and X account remain active, according to Variety.

More entertainment news is on the Stay Current News Entertainment page.