Money

Dow falls 561 points as health insurer stocks slide

The Dow fell 1.1% on Wednesday as UnitedHealth, Humana and Elevance dropped after Medicare officials proposed tougher audits of private insurance plans. The Nasdaq rose.

The columned facade of the New York Stock Exchange in New York City
File photo: Donatingpictures / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

FACTS

Health insurer stocks slid on Wednesday, Nov. 18, and pulled the Dow Jones Industrial Average down 561.64 points, or 1.11%, to 50,197.78, a three-month low, according to Investing.com. The S&P 500 slipped 0.23% to 7,323.52, while the Nasdaq Composite rose 0.42%. The insurers fell after federal Medicare officials proposed tougher audits of private Medicare plans.

Why health insurer stocks fell

UnitedHealth Group fell 10.21% to $349.91 and was the biggest drag on the Dow. In the S&P 500, Humana dropped 12.98% and Elevance Health fell 7.63%, Investing.com reported.

The declines followed a proposed rule from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services called Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, or CRUSH. Investors reacted to the stricter oversight it would bring, TipRanks reported.

What the CMS rule would do

CMS issued the proposed rule on Nov. 16. It covers Medicare, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program and the Affordable Care Act marketplace, according to the CMS fact sheet.

For Medicare Advantage, the private plans that many insurers sell, CMS would change its Risk Adjustment Data Validation audits. These audits check whether plans were overpaid based on how sick their members were reported to be. CMS would start extrapolating audit findings beginning with payment year 2018 audits, and it estimates this would recover about $9 billion in overpayments per payment year on average.

The rule would also make it mandatory for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans to report suspected fraud, waste and abuse to CMS. That reporting is voluntary now. Doctors and other providers who bill Medicare Advantage plans would have to enroll in traditional Medicare.

CMS estimates the full rule would save nearly $90 billion in federal spending from 2027 to 2036. The agency will take public comments for 60 days after the rule is published in the Federal Register.

Each side of the audit debate

The rule would revive the core of a 2023 audit rule that a federal judge in Texas struck down in September 2025, Becker’s Hospital Review reported. The government has appealed that ruling. Analysts at Oppenheimer have suggested the new rule could face a similar court challenge, according to TipRanks.

CMS says the changes are needed to stop overpayments and fraud. The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission has estimated Medicare will spend about 14% more on Medicare Advantage enrollees in 2026 than it would on similar people in traditional Medicare, Becker’s reported.

Other movers

Walt Disney rose 4.63% and Amazon gained 3.82%, leading the Dow higher. Chevron fell 4.74% and Merck lost 3.90%. In the S&P 500, Palo Alto Networks jumped 9.90%.

Oil prices fell. January West Texas Intermediate crude dropped 2.99% to $82.12 a barrel, and Brent crude fell 1.54% to $91.71. Gold futures fell 3.47% to $3,730.10 an ounce.

Stay Current News covered Tuesday’s session in Dow falls 849 points as S&P 500 posts fourth straight loss.