Politics

Judge halts East Potomac Golf Links closure set for Sunday

A federal judge's order keeps the Washington park and golf course open through Nov. 28, blocking a National Park Service closure set for Sunday night.

The Washington Monument seen across a fairway at East Potomac Golf Links
File photo: ~delta / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

FACTS

U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes on Saturday, Nov. 14, issued a temporary restraining order barring the federal government from closing East Potomac Park and East Potomac Golf Links in Washington, according to the court’s order. The National Park Service had planned to close the area at 9 p.m. Sunday, Nov. 15, WJLA reported, as part of a redevelopment of the course pushed by President Donald Trump. The order runs through Nov. 28 unless the court acts sooner.

What the East Potomac Golf Links order requires

The order says the park and the golf course must stay open to the public during the hours they were open as of Nov. 14, including Ohio Drive SW and other areas south of Buckeye Drive SW. It allows routine golf course closures, closures near active seawall repairs and closures for imminent safety threats. For an imminent threat, the government may close the area first but must notify the court and the plaintiffs within 24 hours with a sworn statement from a senior Park Service employee.

The order does not require the government to run the golf course itself. It directs the Interior Department and the Park Service to share the order with their staff by noon Sunday and leaves an earlier preliminary injunction in the case in place.

What each side argued

The lawsuit, DC Preservation League v. Department of Interior, was filed in February by the DC Preservation League and two local golfers. They argue that closing the course and starting work would “irreparably injure plaintiffs and the public interest,” according to the Associated Press.

The Park Service has cited deteriorating buildings, walkways and a seawall, along with limited staffing after the National Links Trust stopped running the course, WJLA reported. Justice Department lawyer Adam Gustafson told the court that all of East Potomac Park was closing for safety reasons and that the National Links Trust’s lease ends on Sunday, according to the AP.

In the order, Reyes wrote that “the justifications presented by NPS for the closure of East Potomac Park are pretextual” on the current record. She wrote that if the safety problems required a closure, the Park Service “would have closed the Park or addressed the issues months ago.” The order also says the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims under federal environmental review law and the Administrative Procedure Act.

Trump’s response

Trump wrote on social media that Reyes “doesn’t want us to quickly and inexpensively fix up the Course which is, also, very dangerous,” the AP reported. He promised Washington area residents a 50% discount on “any and all Rates charged” once the work is done, according to the AP.

Ethics questions raised by the judge

Reyes has said she plans to appoint Jessie Liu, a former U.S. attorney in Washington, to examine whether officials or lawyers violated ethics rules or misled the court, the AP reported. “I think there is enough smoke that someone needs to consider whether there’s been fire,” the judge said, according to the AP. In a Nov. 13 filing, the Justice Department objected, saying there is “no reasonable basis to investigate,” WJLA reported.

The Justice Department has also asked for Reyes to be removed from the case, and she has not stepped aside, the AP reported.

What happens next

A temporary restraining order is a short-term measure that keeps things as they are while a court considers further steps. The order sets no hearing date. It says the court is available Sunday for emergency questions about the order. WJLA reported that it was unclear whether regular golf services would continue at East Potomac.

A separate federal judge has ordered a 14-day pause on work for Trump’s planned arch, the AP reported. Stay Current News reported earlier that the Kennedy family joined the Trump arch lawsuit.

According to the AP, the 106-year-old park includes three golf courses, a miniature golf course and bike lanes.

Photo: File photo of the Washington Monument seen from East Potomac Golf Links. ~delta / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.