FACTS
The Miami-Dade sheriff forfeiture cases brought by a private Coral Gables law firm are now before a Florida appeals court. The Miami-Dade Sheriff’s Office agreed in 2025 to have the Reyes Law Firm handle its civil forfeiture cases in exchange for a share of what is recovered, according to court filings and news reports. Phone businesses whose accounts were frozen say the arrangement violates their right to due process, while the sheriff’s office says it keeps control over the cases.
The Miami-Dade sheriff forfeiture agreement
Rosie Cordero-Stutz was sworn in as Miami-Dade County’s sheriff on Jan. 7, 2025, the first time in nearly 60 years that voters had elected someone to the office, WLRN reported. The oath was administered by Israel Reyes, a former Miami-Dade police detective, prosecutor and circuit judge. About six months later, the sheriff’s office signed an engagement letter with his firm to represent it in civil forfeiture cases, WLRN reported.
Under the agreement, the sheriff’s office pays the firm nothing directly. The firm is paid only from forfeitures it wins. Reason reported, citing court documents, that the fee is 20 percent to 30 percent of each successful recovery, rising if the owner contests the case, seeks a settlement or appeals. The Tampa Bay Times and the ABA Journal reported, citing court papers, that the firm keeps 20 percent to 35 percent of proceeds plus an added 5 percent on appeal.
The seizures
In August 2025, the sheriff’s office seized about $45 million from 16 Miami-area mobile phone businesses, according to Reason. About $42.7 million belonged to SH Americas, which describes itself as South Florida’s largest authorized Samsung distributor. Reason reported that the seizures were part of an investigation into an alleged money laundering scheme and that, according to the Miami Herald, no one at the businesses has been criminally charged.
The businesses’ appeal brief estimates the firm could collect $9 million to $13 million from the seized funds. In court, the firm has also pointed to about $2.6 billion in other assets that it says could be forfeited, which court documents say could carry fees of up to about $480 million, according to Reason. WLRN reported that the trial court found those other funds were outside its jurisdiction and not currently subject to seizure. WLRN also reported that the sheriff’s office’s fines and forfeitures revenue rose from $396,000 in one fiscal year to $9.6 million the next.
What the sheriff’s office says
In April 2026, Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Ariana Fajardo Orshan denied the businesses’ motion to disqualify the firm. She found that the sheriff’s office keeps decision-making authority over the cases, noting that the office must request each prosecution in writing and that its head must approve settlements, according to a Goldwater Institute brief that cites her order.
Lauri Waldman Ross, an attorney for the sheriff’s office, argues the arrangement is lawful because the office oversees the cases and makes the key decisions, the Tampa Bay Times reported. A sheriff’s office spokesman, Det. Argemis Colome, told the Times the office “does not comment on open litigation cases.” Reyes referred questions to the sheriff’s office, the Times reported. Coral Gables Police Chief Ed Hudak, whose department has a similar arrangement, told the Times, “It is a business decision more so than anything else.”
What the businesses and their supporters say
The businesses argue in their October brief to Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal that being prosecuted by counsel who stands to profit from forfeitures violates their due process rights, Reason reported. The case is SH Americas, LLC, et al. v. Miami-Dade County Sheriff’s Office, No. 3D2026-1363.
“The public interest pays the price when the sheriff puts forfeiture prosecutions on commission,” said Lisandra Guerrero, a lawyer for the businesses, according to Reason and the Tampa Bay Times. Timothy Sandefur, vice president for legal affairs at the Goldwater Institute, which filed a brief supporting the businesses, told Reason, “The problem is that it incentivizes a private attorney to create litigation.” The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers wrote that the arrangement could “quickly transform civil forfeiture into an instrument of economic coercion,” Reason reported.
What Florida law says
Florida’s Contraband Forfeiture Act lets law enforcement agencies seek property they believe was used in or obtained through crime. Under section 932.7055 of the Florida Statutes, proceeds go first to liens, then to the agency’s storage and forfeiture costs and court costs, with the rest placed in a special law enforcement trust fund. The section does not mention attorney contingency fees. Reason reported that no Florida court has ruled on contingency fees in civil forfeiture cases.
More national news is on the Stay Current News U.S. page.



